There"s a saying in Yiddish the is based upon a Talmudic aphorism: "A word come the wise is enough."Sound familiar? That"s due to the fact that Benjamin Franklin stated the exact same thing, most famously in his 1758 essay "The way to Wealth," one essay i m sorry is usually a compendium of bad Richard"s sayings strung together. This indicates that over there is an previously instance that the expression in the Franklin corpus, however I don"t feel favor doing the research study to discover it.So does this mean that Benjamin Franklin check out the Talmud? Of course not. The doesn"t even imply the his use of the expression has any type of connection come the Talmud. A clever expression like that can be created multiple times, due to the fact that people are clever. Nearly makes you think in universal human nature, don"t it?I do the efforts to uncover the Talmudic circumstances of the phrase and failed, which ns don"t feeling too negative about; after ~ all, the Talmud is traditionally contrasted to the sea, meaning basically the it is huge. In my find I employed a clever technique, which, though eventually unsuccesful, led me ~ above an exciting journey, the highlights of which ns will currently share.My clue in this search was a little bit of information provided to me through me colleague Naomi Kadar - "Whoever overcome on a teaching in the name of the human who stated it brings freedom to the world" - Pirke Avot 6:6. (Ironically, this saying isn"t attributed.) She stated that the maxim in complete is "A word come the wise is sufficient, but for a silly not even a pole helps," and also that the word for rod is קונדס, which has concerned mean "prankster" in Yiddish. One of the two rival American Yiddish feeling magazines in the early on twentieth century was called דער גרױסער קונדס, "The big Prankster," but the English title on the masthead to be "The big Stick," i m sorry I constantly found puzzling, but which this little bit of details clarified.So making use of this information, I checked out Jastrow - that is, come Marcus Jastrow"s legendary thesaurus of the Targumim, the Talmud Babli and also Yerushalmi, and also the Midrashic Literature, hoping to get what is well-known in the yeshiva together a Jastrow dual - a quote of the very passage that sent out you to the damn dictionary in the first place. No luck. Ns learned, no surprisingly, that this is one of plenty of words that Talmudic Aramaic that space not Semitic in origin, i m sorry you deserve to tell from words itself. It comes from the Greek κοντός, which describes a cavalry lance used an especially on the east frontier that the roman Empire. Cognates exist in Latin, Hungarian, Turkish and also Arabic. Every one of Jastrow"s citations, however, seemed to need to do not v lances, however with poles, and also specifically poles offered to organize things up, such as wedding canopies and also eruvin (boundaries supplied to turn big areas into "homes," in ~ which the Sabbath limit on transferring is looser) and also in one circumstances some regrettably individual"s head and hands. It appeared a tiny odd, though not impossible, that the feeling would be so various in the Talmud, however then ns remembered the Naomi claimed that the kind of the word was קונדסא, which make sense, since in Aramaic a א at the finish of a word is regularly a definite article. Jastrow go indeed have actually the indigenous קונדסא, however it is a unit the measurement supplied for artichokes. Seriously.

You are watching: A word to the wise is sufficient

*
The native is a corruption that קינרס "artichoke," indigenous the Greek κινάρες (accusative plural), cognate with words for "artichoke" in numerous languages, and familiar to me from mine days functioning in a liquor store, where we marketed (though nobody bought) Cynar, an Italian apero (bitter apéritif) flavored v artichokes.At this allude I"m tempted to say other flaky around the trip being more important than the destination, back I normally hate stuff choose that. So rather I"ll quote the Franklin aphorism in full, which prefer its Talmudic counterpart, has actually a hardly ever quoted 2nd part:"A word to the wise is enough, and also many indigenous won"t fill a bushel."And on that note:"Of do of books there is no end, and also much examine is a weariness that the flesh." Ecclesiastes 12:12.A PostscriptWikipedia gives the adhering to Latin versions of the saying:Terence Phormio, IIII.3: Verbum satellite sapienti.Plautus Pseudolus, act I.1: Dictum sapienti sat est.Thomas à Kempis Imitation of Christ (c.1481), 3.34: Intelligenti satis dictum est.Franklin can have gained it from any kind of of these. Or make it up himself. In fact, the Talmud can have acquired it from one of two people of the very first two. Goddammit. I created my cursed BA thesis top top the opportunity of Greco-Roman influences on the Talmud, and also I never knew about this. Just goes to present you: friend can"t assignment "blah lol blah" without BA. Or "a poor grad student" without ABD.On the other hand, this support a pet concept of mine the most well known quotations generally have many antecedents. I have actually a variety of other theories about famous quotations, which will be the subject of my next post, uneven anyone has any type of requests.
Posted byBenat2:07 PM
*

the cacao doctor מרת שאקאלאדsaid...

The Talmud has a measure word for Artichokes! i love that. I want to make a blog-unit about it, but what can I say except "The talmud has actually a measure word because that artichokes"?But, Ben, please do not save us in suspense for one more second! I must knowHOW plenty of ARTICHOKES are THERE IN A KUNDASA???!!!??

11:37 PMBensaid...

How numerous artichokes in a kundasa? Jastrow doesn"t say, and also the i he cites don"t yes, really clarify, although because it is a "מודיא" it is most likely weight based. I know that the object of weights and also measurements is renowned right now, so there are most likely sforim that talk about this really issue. Or not. Actually, rereading the Jastrow entry ns can"t call if the is speak kundasa method "artichokes" or "a designation of a particular modius." I"ll upload photo of the entry and you deserve to pasken for yourself.As because that the post, here"s one idea: perform you have a copy the Jastrow? Flip about - each entry is post-worthy, it seems, and I"m sure there"s a good deal that food and drink connected craziness. הפוך בה והפוך בה דכולו בה

11:02 AMthe coco doctor מרת שאקאלאדsaid...

I am sure each entrance is post worthy. Ns really should have actually a Jastrow--It will certainly be mine valentine to my blog (and myself).

12:27 PMשלום בערגער Zackary Bergersaid...

די לחכימא ברמיזא.

8:33 PMBensaid...

!אַ שײנעם דאַנק, שלוםBut what"s it from? and do you know the rest?

10:31 AMeinatsaid...

Dear Ben, as Naomi's daughter, ns was really moved to read this. If you receive this message, please acquire in touch. Ns love connecting with human being who operated with my mother. My email is ekadar
gmail.com. Take it care, and also thanks for writing all of this down...Einat Kadar

2:12 PMMaxsaid...

See more: What If The Black Death Never Happened ? What If The Black Death Never Occurred

Hello! I have the right to recommend a website that has actually helped me. I’s dubbed WritePaper.Info They assisted me for creating my quality research paper on diabetes, and also of course by keeping my all other requirements fulfilled.

2:50 PMzalmysaid...

https://he.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%93%D7%99_%D7%9C%D7%97%D7%9B%D7%99%D7%9E%D7%90_%D7%91%D7%A8%D7%9E%D7%99%D7%96%D7%90