Film flops through lead actor"s horrendous belting linked with Emmy Rossum"s timid vocals


Photo Courtesy of Giphy User

But in 2004, the long-gestating film variation was lastly released, come the bile of pan everywhere. Certification the insanity miscast Gerard Butler together the Phantom and Emmy Rossum as the thing of his affection, Christine, this version of “Phantom” was directed by the infamous Joel Schumacher. Yes, the “Batman and also Robin” Joel Schumacher.

You are watching: Did gerard butler sing in phantom of the opera

Big bads: ‘Batman & Robin’ pipeline audiences feeling like they need a heroIn 1997, well known director Joel Schumacher practically ruined comic books for everyone with the abomination the was “Batman & Robin.” Read…

This movie is therefore amateurish, therefore unambitious, therefore spectacularly incompetent that it provides the “Rent” movie, which come out the year after, look choose a masterpiece. The worry most glaringly apparent to the layman is Butler and also Rossum. Plain and also simple, they can’t sing. Butler’s is worse at first — he’s really much more screaming than singing.

During “Music of the Night,” one of the Phantom’s signature numbers, he desecrates one of the many beautiful song in recent Broadway memory. There room too many problems with his to sing to list, yet the worst is his belting. Anytime he lets his chest increase and shot to sing at full power, it come out as a guttural yell. It sound genuinely awful, especially when contrasted to human being like Michael Crawford and also Ramin Karimloo that lend your spectacular voices to the role.

Rossum is candid no better. Though her voice is somewhat an ext aesthetically pleasing, her lack of training and confidence is painfully obvious. Rossum was only 17-years-old once this film came out, and it shows.

If you listen to “Think the Me,” Christine’s first real showcase, it falls massively level in the movie. Rossum just does not have a voice top top the level of sarah Brightman or Sierra Boggess, and while she can marginally carry a tune, she bring very little to it.

Big Bads: with ‘Anonymous’ Robert Emmerich made brand-new kind of disaster movieRoland Emmerich is ideal known for damaging landmarks in catastrophe movies prefer “Independence Day” and “Godzilla,” sometimes deciding to do Read…

Looking past the disappointed Butler and Rossum, the rest of the film just does no work. Schumacher, in every his incompetence, cannot regulate to consistently develop compelling frames. Also with the miserable performances from the two leads, this film’s biggest failings come native the technological aspects.

John Mathieson, director of photography for the film, to be nominated for an Oscar for his work, which is fully baffling. The cinematography ~ above “Phantom” is abysmal. Virtually every collection is overlit and miniscule, a poor enough crime in and of itself. Yet the usage of different shots is mystifying. There room so numerous long takes where there must not be long takes, presumably to hide how pitifully small the to adjust are. And also when a long take could impart some level of feel on a frame, Mathieson and Schumacher employ cuts instead.

See more: Ask A Scientist: How Much Psi Should A Basketball Have ? Basketball Air Pressure

While Mathieson has actually done some other an excellent work, such as “X-Men: very first Class” and also “Gladiator,” the crap seems to outweigh the good. His résumé is also loaded v abysmal flops prefer “Pan” and also “47 Ronin.”

Honestly, there room enough problems in this movie, including comparisons to the initial show, the publication it’s adapted from and the multitude of other adaptations come prattle on for thousands and thousands of words.

But because that now, content yourself through the fact that you can probably sing “Music of the Night” far better than Gerard Butler.