The finished shape of the bullet more than likely has much more to execute with the as whole effect — bullets through sharp edges can slice blood vessels quite than tear them, resulting in a more rapid bleed out

The latest fad in regulation enforcement is to adjust from a bigger sidearm caliber come the 9mm. I’ve constantly believed drilling bigger holes does a far better job of preventing dangerous adversaries, but I’ve spent an ext years pack a 9mm pistol than any kind of other caliber, and never felt under-gunned.

You are watching: How many bullets does a pistol hold

The price on even if it is or not an officer — or legally equipped citizen, for that issue — should choose 9mm over another cartridge is, “it depends.” It counts on what gives the operator the highest possible level of to trust in win the fight. 

That having actually been said, let’s examine few of the factors which weigh into the decision come go through one cartridge end another. 

Related articles

1. Contemporary bullet technology has make the 9mm as reliable as enlarge calibers.The “high-tech 9mm bullets” debate only holds water if girlfriend pretend the improved bullet technologies haven’t been applied to all other pistol calibers. Indeed, modern-day 9mm projectiles — prefer bonded draft or the all-copper Barnes TAC-Xp hollow points — do provide much much more reliable expansion and penetration attributes than older designs.

But .40 and also .45 caliber TAC-XPs provide proportionately better expansion/penetration than older design in those calibers. 

A “new” 9mm style might same the power of an larger .45 design, however falls simply as much behind as soon as you to compare apples to apples. Police bullets commonly need to defeat car glass and this is a simple matter the mass; the larger bullets will constantly do more damage to the target after being shredded by the glass.

Let’s to compare the three most usual police sidearm cartridges in the most typical sidearm. I’ll usage the velocity worths from black Hills Ammunition’s heat of Barnes Tac-XP bullets in the chart due to the fact that I have the correlating gelatin expansion/penetration data. Is the larger hole precious the added recoil?

The volume that the permanent cavity calculated from increased diameter and depth that penetration. Check out the chart below, and click on that if you would like to watch a bigger version.

ns will constantly carry the biggest drill ns can, so my choice for open/duty carry is one of two people a .45 because that social work or a full-power 10mm in the boondocks. Once I need a little pistol because that concealment, a 9mm through high-tech ammo will certainly do.

2. Less recoil makes the 9mm easier to shoot, specifically for “small statured” officers.Shooting — including the recoil aspect — is mainly a psychological exercise, no physical. I newly saw a small-statured female go through basic police training through a Glock 22. Her hand was almost fully around the best side of the pistol for her finger to with the trigger. She no top-gun in her class — and needed remedial training to happen — but pass she did. Like other aspects of a regime skewed in donate of big guys, she mentally made decision to succeed — and also did. 

Would the reduced recoil that a 9mm make the difference between passing and also failing through some trainees? Maybe. A smaller sized grip frame would aid marginal performers much more than lighter recoil. I’ve watched some damn small shooters handle a .45 caliber single-stack pistol like a champ.

If we ever see a contemporary striker-fired pistol v a single-stack magazine, little officers will have the many tractable sidearm possible, allowing any caliber to fit your hand. Space you listening Glock? because that those who can handle a .45 effectively, why not lug the many power available.

3. The 9mm pistols have a greater capacity, so pack much more rounds because that the fight.Again, presume you’re using Glock pistols, a fully loaded version 17 (9mm) amounts to 18 rounds. You have 16 rounds with the design 22 (.40 S&W) in the exact same size package. 

If girlfriend can’t resolve a street shooting difficulty with 16 rounds of .40, ns seriously doubt two additional rounds the 9mm will certainly make much difference — reload! 

4. 9mm ammunition expenses less, enabling us come shoot more.Precious steels sell by the pound. The less metal you usage to make a cartridge, the less it will certainly cost.

I take into consideration lead, zinc, copper, and tin come historically it is in the most precious steels (the base metals needed come manufacture weapons ranging from bronze-age swords to modern firearms ammunition). Background teaches united state that those human being with the many lead/zinc/copper/tin have tendency to take all the gold and silver lock desire.

See more: What Is 1/3 As A Whole Number S As Fractions (Video), What Is 1/3 As A Whole Number

ConclusionThe bottom line? Shot location trumps every — a 9mm bullet hitting center-mass is an ext effective than a .45 top top the edge. The 9mm to represent the smallest cartridge suitable for a duty pistol — the is adequate. The .40 S&W drills a considerably bigger hole, in ~ the cost of an ext wear and tear ~ above the pistols and complaints about “snappy” recoil. 

The venerable .45 reasons the best wounds and many find it an ext comfortable come shoot than a smaller .40 caliber pistol. The .357 Sig and also .45 void cartridges represent a very small percentage the police pistols and also their small numbers result in greatly increased ammo costs. 

Finally, because pictures are worth a thousand words (and the is about what mine word counting is because that this article), examine out the bullet/gelatin images from black Hills Ammunition (loaded v Barnes all-copper projectiles) in the Related posts box above and come the left. Those links are titled, 9mm Luger 115 grain Tac-XP +P, .40 S&W 140 grain Tac-XP, and .45 ACP 185 serial Tac-XP +P. Check those, consider the above, and make the an option that"s appropriate for you. 



Dick Fairburn has an ext than 40 year of legislation enforcement experience in both Illinois and Wyoming, functioning patrol, investigations and also administrative assignments. Dick also served together the ar chief of a major academy's firearms Training Unit and vital incident maintain program. He has actually a B.S. In regulation Enforcement administration from western Illinois University and also was the Valedictorian of his recruit class at the Illinois State Police Academy. He has published more than 300 function articles and also two books: "Police Rifles" and "Building a better Gunfighter." dick is right now serving as the public security director in a central Illinois community, overseeing the police and fire departments, and also the 911 center.