When Holden finishes his conversation v the two nuns, the is virtually noon. He has actually two hours until that is to fulfill Sally in ~ the Biltmore Hotel for this reason he goes because that a walk toward Broadway. He wants to to buy a recording, for Phoebe, of an old song called "Little Shirley Beans." follow me the way, Holden notices an reportedly underprivileged family walking residence from church. The young child is walking in the street and singing.

You are watching: Little shirley beans catcher in the rye

Fortunately, the very first music store that that visits has a copy the the record. Holden tries to telephone Jane, but her mom answers therefore he hangs up. Tho burdened through the obligation of procuring theater tickets, he chooses a play, I know My Love, that he thinks Sally will like due to the fact that it stars the Lunts. That decides come visit main Park in hopes of recognize Phoebe who frequently skates there on Sundays. He almost visits the Museum the Natural history but decides no to walk in. Although that doesn"t feel favor going with with the date, he records a cab to fulfill Sally at the Biltmore Hotel as planned.

Analysis

Much the the thing is specialized to Holden"s considerations of creative performances. Merely put, he likes what he find to be authentic and also dislikes what that sees together phony. The dominating theme the the remainder of the chapter is the mutability the time and its connection to death.

The first example that Holden"s aesthetics in chapter 16 is the recording that he wants to buy because that Phoebe, one old song around a shy boy who won"t go out of she house since she is lacking two former teeth. That is referred to as "Little Shirley Beans" and also is sung through the black jazz singer Estelle Fletcher. What Holden likes is that it is authentic. Regardless of the topic, it is no maudlin nor sentimental. The artist sings that "very Dixieland and whorehouse," no all mushy and cute the way he thinks a white girl would carry out it. Holden repetitively holds in contempt any type of artist who caters to the audience at the price of the occupational of art, also a song about a girl missing two prior teeth. He feels the same way about Ernie"s piano playing orD.B."s writing. Holden pays 5 dollars because that the recording at a time when most records can be purchased because that fifty cent or less.

A less professional example of authenticity is the child on the street. The is "swell" due to the fact that he walk his very own way. The parents are on the sidewalk, but the child marches follow me the street, alongside the curb, singing, "If a body capture a human body coming with the rye." He has actually a nice voice and also is just singing "for the hell that it." dare zoom by, part apparently having to screech your brakes to miss out on the boy, but he is no perturbed. Because that Holden, this is pure, innocent, and real, a living example of arts for art"s services although the does no state it that way. The power is the much better because no the son nor Holden, his just audience, bring away it an extremely seriously. The occasion brightens Holden"s day. The step is even more far-ranging because the foreshadows Salinger"s revelation the the main metaphor the the novel, the resource of the novel"s title, in chapter 22.

In contrast are movies and also the theater. It "depresses hell" the end of Holden when world make too lot of going come a movie, specifically when they kind lines every the way down the block. Live performances are just as bad. He hates Broadway, and he no actors, also the so-called "great" performers prefer Sir Laurence Olivier. As soon as D.B. Took Phoebe and also Holden to view Olivier"s legendary performance in Shakespeare"s Hamlet, Holden didn"t much care for it. He thought that Olivier to be handsome and had a great voice but acted an ext like a basic than a "sad, screwed-up" male struggling to uncover his way, i beg your pardon is what he thought the pat was supposed to be about. Holden generally does not gain performances due to the fact that he is pertained to that the actors will perform something phony at nearly any moment. Also if an actor is good, Holden think the actor acts as though he knows he"s an excellent and end up pandering come the audience the method Ernie does as soon as he dram the piano. Audiences commonly can"t distinguish in between phony and also authentic, as Holden sees it, and also applaud at every the wrong times.

The chapter"s other major theme is the mutability the time and also its connection to death. At the park, Holden runs right into a schoolmate the Phoebe"s who argues that Holden"s sister can be at the museum, "the one with the Indians." the proves to be unlikely, because it is Sunday and Phoebe"s class would no be meeting, but mention that the Museum that Natural background triggers memories because that Holden. The attended Phoebe"s school when he was she age and also toured the exact same museum. He likes come think that the museum would be pretty much the same if he access time it now, however it bothers him come think the he has changed. Phoebe, too, will certainly change. Life is change, as most of us learn, yet Holden doesn"t desire to accept that. That likes the glass situations in the museum the freeze a minute of history in time and also space. One Eskimo, for example, might be fishing v a feet in the ice. The very same Eskimo to be there when Holden checked out the museum and will it is in there because that Phoebe once she visits. Holden would like it if our lives, too, could be frozen in time. That is one adolescent see of the world, the motive behind a young person"s saying to a friend, "Don"t ever before change." The great is impossible, but it is common by Holden. He"d surely prefer to freeze particular moments through Allie or Phoebe for every time: "Certain things they must stay the means they are. Friend ought to be able to stick them in one of those big glass cases and also just leaving them alone." In Holden"s world, good things would never ever die.

Glossary

Broadway street to run north and also south through new York City, well-known as the facility of the city"s main theater and also entertainment section.

the Lunts Alfred Lunt (1893-1977) and Lynn Fontanne (1887-1983), husband and also wife, to be revered stage actors that the day, regularly performing together.

See more: 60 Is 30 Is 60 Percent Of What Number ? Solved: 30 Is 60 Percent Of What Number

Flys Up a baseball or soft ball playground video game in which the fielder who catches a fly round is enabled to bat next.