Summary: action I, scene iii

Shylock, a Jewish moneylender, agrees come loan Bassanio three thousand ducats because that a hatchet of 3 months. Bassanio assures Shylock the Antonio will certainly guarantee the loan, but Shylock is doubtful since Antonio’s riches is right now invested in organization ventures that may fail. In the end, however, Shylock decides that Antonio’s insurance of the loan will be enough assurance, and also asks to speak v him. As soon as Antonio arrives, Shylock, in an aside, confesses his hatred for the man. Antonio, Shylock says, is a Christian that lends money without interest, which makes more complicated the exercise of usury, in which money is lent out at exorbitant attention rates. Shylock is likewise incensed by Antonio’s frequent public blame to of Shylock. Antonio provides it clean to Shylock the he is no in the habit of borrowing or lending money, however has determined to make an exemption on behalf of his girlfriend Bassanio. Their conversation leader Antonio to chastise the organization of usury, which Shylock defends as a method to thrive.

You are watching: What punishment does antonio negotiate for shylock

As that calculates the attention on Bassanio’s loan, Shylock remembers the plenty of times the Antonio has actually cursed him, calling him a “misbeliever, cut-throat, dog / and also spit ~ above Jewish gaberdine” (I.iii.107–108). Antonio responds the he is most likely to perform so again, and insists that Shylock lend him the money as an enemy. Together an arrangement, Antonio claims, will make it less complicated for Shylock to precise a harsh punish if the loan is no repaid. Assuring Antonio that he method to it is in friends, Shylock supplies to make the loan there is no interest. Instead, the suggests, look at in jest, the Antonio forfeit a lb of his own flesh need to the loan not be repaid in early time. Bassanio advises Antonio against entering such an agreement, however Antonio assures him the he will have actually no problem repaying the debt, together his ships will soon carry him riches that much exceeds the worth of the loan. Shylock attempts to dismiss Bassanio’s suspicions, questioning what profit he was standing to do by procuring a lb of Antonio’s flesh. As Shylock heads turn off to the notary’s office to sign the bond, Antonio remarks on Shylock’s newfound generosity: “The Hebrew will turn Christian; he grows kind” (I.iii.174). Bassanio stays suspicious of the arrangement, yet Antonio reminds him the his ships will certainly arrive in ~ the next two months.

Read a translation of plot I, scene iii →

Analysis

Shylock is an arresting visibility on the stage, and also although Antonio may be the character for whom the play is named, it is Shylock that has involved dominate the imaginations of critics and also audiences alike. Shylock’s physical visibility in the pat is actually not so large, together he speaks under lines than various other characters and does no even appear in the play’s final act. However, in countless ways, the beat belongs come Shylock. The usage of a Jew together the central villain was not unknown come Renaissance comedy, as confirmed by The Jew the Malta, a wildly famous play through Shakespeare’s modern Christopher Marlowe, i m sorry revolves around a malevolent, bloodthirsty Jewish character called Barabas. Shylock, however, differs in that his malice appears to stem, at the very least in part, native the unkindness the his Christian colleagues. Exactly how to read Shylock has actually been a matter of part debate, and also even the many persuasive scholars would certainly be hard-pressed to contact him a flattering portrait the a Jew. One could absolutely argue, however, that Shylock receives much less the a stock portrayal than what was typical in Shakespeare’s time, and that, given the constant degradation that endures, us can also feel something akin come sympathy because that him.

At the love of any kind of sympathy we might feel because that Shylock lies the truth that the bonhomie and an excellent nature the so mark Antonio’s appearance through Bassanio disappear, and his therapy of Shylock is suddenly harsh and also brutal. Even though Bassanio and also Antonio require a donate from Shylock, Antonio’s is quiet a ton of imperious command, and also his past, present, and future mindset toward Shylock is among exceptional contempt. Shylock vividly illustrates the depth that this contempt, wondering aloud why he need to lend Antonio money as soon as Antonio has voided his “rheum,” or spit, on Shylock’s beard, and also he kicked Shylock together he would certainly a stray dog (I.iii.113–114). The repeated mention of spittle below sharply differentiates Antonio’s Venice, where even shipwrecks seem favor spice-laden dreams, indigenous Shylock’s, whereby the city is a location of blows, kicks, and bodily functions. Without this details, Antonio’s haughty perspective toward Shylock can easily it is in forgiven, but the really visceral details of spit and kicks display a violent, much less romantic side to Antonio, and our sympathies for him cannot aid but lessen.

Shylock is noticeably different from Shakespeare’s other great villains, such together Richard III or Iago, in several ways. In the very first place, these various other villains view themselves together evil, and also while lock may shot to justification their own villainy, they likewise revel in it, making asides to the audience and also self-consciously comparing themselves to the Vice character of middle ages morality plays. Marlowe’s Jew, Barabas, is a similarly self-conscious villain. Though the Christian characters of The vendor of Venice might view Jews as evil, Shylock go not watch himself in that way. His see of himself and also others are rational, articulate, and consistent. Also, Shakespeare’s various other villains space generally more deceitful, passing themselves off together loving and also virtuous believer while plot malevolently against those about them. Shylock, top top the various other hand, is one outcast even before the pat begins, vilified and spat ~ above by the Christian characters. Shylock’s plot are relatively open, although the other characters misunderstand his intentions due to the fact that they do not understand him.

See more: What Is Grammar School On An Application Process, Apply Online

Indeed, Shylock understands the Christians and their society much far better than they understand him. The Christian characters only communicate with Shylock within a framework of finance and also law—he is not component of the friendship network depicted in act I, scene i. Though Bassanio asks him to dine v them, Shylock states in an aside that he will certainly not rest bread through Christians, nor will certainly he forgive Antonio, in order to signaling his refusal of among the basic Christian values, forgiveness. Shylock is maybe to point out the new Testament as conveniently as Jewish scripture, as he shows in his remark about the pig being the animal into i beg your pardon Christ drive the devil. Antonio notes Shylock’s facility with the Bible, but he offers this capability to to compare Shylock come the devil, who, proverbially, is additionally adept at quoting scripture. As we see more of Shylock, that does not become a hero or a fully sympathetic character, but he is an unsettling figure insofar together he exposes the inconsistencies and hypocrisies of the Christian characters. Shylock never ever quite fits your descriptions or expectation of him. Many significantly, castle think that is urged solely by money, once in reality his resentment against Antonio and the other Christians outweighs his desire for financial gain.