Contrasting student and scientific views

Student daily experiences

*
the is very complicated to tell with the nude eye if an item is accelerating (for example, a ball flying through the air) and also so students perform not have tendency to think of activity in terms of whether that is increased or not. Sped up motion is also a an overwhelming concept for students because it occurs when an item changes either speed or direction or both. Students are acquainted with objects increasing from rest or braking, for example a car speeding up or come a lesser level slowing under at the traffic lights. However, the is lot more difficult to recognize if one object currently moving is transforming its speed unless the readjust is dramatic. Students seldom identify a car transforming a corner at continuous speed as speeding up because their usual understanding requires the thing to be changing speed for it to it is in accelerating.

You are watching: Which is not a big idea involving force and motion

Even senior students consistently confuse ‘acceleration’ and also ‘speed’; for example they might think that if speed is raising then acceleration is likewise increasing.

Research: Champagne, Klopfer & Anderson (1980), Trowbridge & McDermott (1981), Loughran, Berry & Mulhall (2006)

Students often have a set of ‘intuitive rules’ the seem to explain everyday instances of activity (see the teaching principles on forces and motion in ~ the lower levels). These rules appear to job-related when students neglect friction and air resistance; friction and also air resistance are generally not seen by student as entailing forces.

These concepts are additionally discussed in the emphasis idea Friction is a Force.

Research: Mitchell (2007)

A typical view the persists at this level is the a relocating object must have actually a pressure acting on them in the direction of their motion. Some students likewise strongly believe that this pressure is being used up if the object is slowly down. This might be partially a terminology problem: what students brand as a force in these instances is comparable to what scientists call ‘momentum’.

Research: Champagne, Klopfer & Anderson (1980), Gunstone & watts (1985), Gunstone, Mulhall & McKittrick (2007), Osborne & Freyberg (1985)

Students frequently struggle to master the principle of net force, and often think it is one extra pressure in enhancement to the actual pressures on an object.

Research: Gunstone, Mulhall & McKittrick (2007)

Scientific view

The net pressure is the merged effect (the sum) of the real forces acting top top the object. Net pressure is a an useful construct that has actually no separate existence of its own, unlike the real pressures acting top top the object, i.e. It is not second force.

Research: Gunstone, Mulhall & McKittrick (2007)

While the net pressure on things is zero, its speed and direction of activity remain the same (and stationary objects stay stationary). Check out Newton’s an initial law that motion.

When over there is a net pressure on an object, it causes the object to accelerate in the direction of the net force; this is not the same as the direction the the movement unless the thing is going in a straight line. The magnitude of the net force on the thing is the product the its mass and also its acceleration (Newton’s second law of motion).

Critical to teach ideas

An object accelerates when that is speed transforms or that is direction the motion transforms or both.Changes in one object’s speed room always consistent even despite in some cases it may show up to be nearly instantaneous (for example a golf ball once hit by a golf club, or automobile collisions).The net force on things is the combined effect (the sum) of all the pushing and pulling pressures actually exhilaration on the object.If the pressures pushing or pulling on an object are not balanced (a net force acts) then the object will certainly accelerate in the direction the the net force.

Research: Loughran, Berry & Mulhall (2006), Gunstone, Mulhall & McKittrick (2007)

*
Explore the relationships in between ideas around force and acceleration in the Concept advance Maps – laws of Motion

The ideas about forces and motion below contribute to student understanding of this topic. These space each covered in greater information in the succession of teaching concepts introduced in ~ the lower levels:

A net force on an item changes its activity – the better the net force, the better the acceleration. Much more massive objects call for bigger net pressures to accelerate the same amount as less huge objects.A pressure is explained by using the expression ‘force that A ~ above B’ and drawing an arrowhead to present the direction that the force. Because that example, the weight of a book is the ‘force of planet on the book’. It have the right to be represented diagrammatically through an arrowhead drawn through the centre of the book directed downwards in the direction of the Earth.

It is important for students to have a sound qualitative knowledge of the ideas of Newton’s second law before mathematics is introduced. Students need exposure to cases that need verbal explanations about the forces involved before they space exposed come quantitative work including formulae.

A straightforward mathematical connection exists in between the massive of an object (m), the net force on the thing (f) and also its acceleration (a). The acceleration of an item is straight proportional to the net force and indirectly proportional come the object’s mass (a = f/m).

Teaching activities

Opening up discussion via a shared experience

Students have to use the expression ‘force the A top top B’ to determine the agent and also receiver the a force in assorted situations, and use an arrowhead to represent the force’s direction. They have the right to then it is in asked to identify all the actual forces and also the net force on objects in a wide selection of activity contexts. Some instances include: a round rolling follow me a table; a ball that to be rolling ~ above a table but is now stopped; a ball thrown increase in the air the is moving upwards (or downwards); a skateboard rider relocating down a tenderness sloping course at a constant speed.

In particular, the role of friction needs to be explored due to the fact that it has actually such a large influence ~ above the observed motion of daily objects.

Ideas around friction space explored in the focus idea Friction is a force.

Open up conversation via a common experience

*
POE (Predict-Observe-Explain) deserve to be used to develop powerful understandings about balanced and unbalanced forces. Using a bicycle wheel an installed as a pulley, through a bucket of sand hanging from either side, students can respond come each inquiry below. They need to observe what happens and also then define their observation:

With one bucket (A) higher than the various other (B), and also both hosted stationary, ask the students which weighs more.With A pulled down so it is level through B, ask students come predict what will happen when you let go of A.Return to (1) and ask for college student predictions around the effect of including a little weight to B – will certainly either next move, how far?The exact same as collection up together above, but with a lot heavier load (so that will cause movement). Ask students even if it is B’s rate is the exact same at two widely separated clues in that is path.Explore the impacts of including and subtracting huge and little weights if the buckets room moving. There are numerous possibilities below which have the right to foster better student engagement if castle are motivated to indicate some of these brand-new possibilities.

Research: Loughran, Berry & Mul​hall (2006)

Challenge existing ideas

P.O.E ar a puck on air table and also ask students come predict how they would keep it relocating at a steady rate by pushing on it v a ruler. Most students room surprised that it is difficult to attain a steady speed with this activity and are intrigued as any type of amount of press with the ruler provides the puck store "running away from them".

Promote enjoy on and also clarification of existing ideas

Road security is a topic wherein students can check out the issues associated with mass and speed the vehicles affiliated in car accidents and just how these may affect the injuries inflicted on passengers.

Encourage students come think that the advantages of introducing light weight vehicles and also the flaw of being involved in collisions with much heavier trucks.

The Digilearn objects below provide some simulations students can experiment with.

Promote have fun on just how student concepts have changed

Students have the right to look for examples in films and also cartoons where Newton’s legislations are no obeyed. The famous ‘Coyote and the roadway Runner’ cartoons use frequent scenes where students’ alternate conceptions are displayed. Identify situations and discuss this in class.

Collect evidence/data because that analysis

Data loggers have the right to be supplied to record and graph students’ movement and the movement of various other objects. Utilise software program programs that have the right to analyse video (or digitally recorded) motion.

See more: New York Central Park Zip Code, 1 Central Park West Unit 26

Further resources

Science associated interactive discovering objects can be discovered on the FUSE Teacher resources page.

To accessibility the interactive learning object below, teachers need to login come FUSE and search by Learning source ID:

Accelerate - Pilot a spaceship between planets. Usage Newton"s 2nd law of motion to work out the acceleration necessary in a collection of challenges. Journey at a consistent acceleration, then do adjustments because that cargo and also friction. Research velocity-time heat graphs reflecting acceleration together the gradient. This discovering object is a mix of three finding out objects in the exact same series.Learning source ID: UM9P74 It’s a drag – Students inspection the braking efficiency of cars and trucks. They check stopping distances under controlled conditions and compare effects of automobile type, speed, tyres, roadway surface and also weather conditions.Learning source ID:  W2XXLR