In the Disney classic Aladdin (1992), Aladdin is warned not to touch anything other than the lamp. However Both he and Apu touch the magic carpet, Carpet. Why to be Carpet excluded from that rule?


*

Because they never touched it with their hands through the intentionally to take it it favor Abu did through the diamond/ruby shining thing. Castle stood top top it with their feet, i m sorry is usually what carpets are for anyway. I understand technically poignant would average touching, yet I think it didn"t use when castle stood top top the carpet, since they (the writers/studio etc) needed them to communicate with carpet at the very least a little, zb standing on him, to wake up him increase and an alert there was world in the cavern for the an initial time in a millenia to give him a factor for interacting with them. Plus, it"s a cartoon through a parrot that has bigger vocabulary 보다 the dictionary, a genie, a talking panther cave, and also many more things that are method weirder than why the cave didn"t collapse as soon as they stood on the rug.

You are watching: You have touched the forbidden treasure


re-superstructure
enhance this price
follow
edited Aug 29 "18 at 5:07
*

A J♦
56.5k2727 gold badges288288 silver badges309309 bronze title
answer Aug 29 "18 in ~ 1:41
*

D0S81D0S81
10211 silver badge11 bronze argorial
1
add a comment |
10
I don"t recognize if there is a canonical prize here however for me, the implication is that they are not to touch any type of of the treasure. After every they were emotional the ground by go on it, so plainly "touch nothing", did no literally typical to touch nothing.

But climate one could argue the a magic carpet is component of the treasure also so it have to still use to the "touch nothing" statement. If we"re strict talking around the Disney cartoon, one might say the the carpet didn"t use because it was alive. Likewise the carpet initiated the physical call if ns remember properly which renders it unfair to encompass in the "touch nothing" rule. They didn"t touch the carpet, the carpet touch them.

But if girlfriend ask me, i think the "touch nothing" dominance was merely meant to apply to the gold and silver and gems the one would certainly obviously be tempted to to fill one"s pockets with.

One should also note that relying on the variation of the story, there may or might not have been a magic carpet. According to Wikipedia:

Aladdin, the 1992 animated feature by Walt Disney Feature animation (possibly currently the finest known re-telling of the story). In this variation several characters are change the name or amalgamated (for circumstances the Sorcerer and also the Sultan"s vizier come to be the same person, named "Jafar", when the Princess is re-named "Jasmine"), have brand-new motivations for your actions (the lamp Genie now desires freedom from his role) or are simply replaced (a magic carpet filling the place of the Ring Genie in the plot, when a royal "magic ring" is offered by Jafar to discover Aladdin). Surname from and also elements that the 1940 live-action The Thief the Baghdad are borrowed (for instance, the surname "Jafar" and "Abu" and also the Sultan"s pleasure in toys). The setting is relocated from China come the fictitious Arabian city the Agrabah, and also the structure of the plot is simplified.

The magic carpet to be likely brought into the 1992 Disney version of Aladdin due to the fact that of the popularity of a flying magic carpet in middle Eastern folklore.

See more: How Many Kilometers Are In Centimeters, Cm To Km Converter

EDIT:Per Richard"s comment, the movie manuscript for Disney"s Aladdin in reality condemns them as follows

Cave: You have touched the forbidden treasure! (ABU areas the jewel earlier into the paw, yet the jewel and the shrine melt right into lava.) currently you will never ever again watch the irradiate of day!

This line shows that what was no to be touched was the sweetheart itself and not absolutely everything in the cave.